Lucy Pet's Mom's Meatloaf Dinner Roll is a 4 lb semi-moist chicken roll with visible carrots and spinach mixed in, but its 3.2 star average across 227 reviews is one of the lower ratings in this category, so it's worth weighing carefully against higher-rated alternatives.
Owners looking for a larger, semi-moist roll with visible vegetable pieces who don't mind a food with a more mixed review history.
Skip if
You want a highly rated option, since 3.2 stars is below most competing rolls, or your dog has shown sensitivity to casing-style semi-moist foods before.
Form Roll
Flavor Chicken
Benefits Supports Healthy Skin, Coat, Heart, And Eyes
Best for Appetite Stimulation, Sensitive Stomach, Skin And Coat Health
Breed size All
Our scorecard
3.3/5overall
Owner rating3.2/5
3.2 average across 227 owner ratings
Popularity1.7/5
227 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other dog food and health supplements we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
["This 4 lb Dinner Roll from Lucy Pet is a chicken-based, semi-moist food with visible carrot and spinach pieces mixed in, wrapped in a casing format. It's labeled corn-free and wheat-free, and marketed for all breed sizes and life stages.", 'Lucy Pet points to appetite stimulation, sensitive stomach support, and skin and coat health as the main benefits, with kelp and sweet potato added alongside the carrot and spinach. The semi-moist roll format is designed to stand out with visible real vegetables rather than a uniform pate texture.', "At $24.69 for 4 lb, it's priced for the larger size, but with 227 reviews averaging 3.2 stars and no recent purchase volume reported, buyer sentiment here trails several other rolls in this category."]
Pros
Larger 4 lb size compared to many 1 lb rolls
Corn-free, wheat-free recipe with visible carrot and spinach pieces
Contains kelp and sweet potato in addition to the core chicken base
Marketed for sensitive stomach and skin and coat support
Cons
3.2 star rating is notably lower than most competing dog food rolls
No recent purchase volume reported
Casing-style semi-moist format may not suit every dog's preference
Specifications
Form
Roll
Flavor
Chicken
Benefits
Supports Healthy Skin, Coat, Heart, And Eyes
Best for
Appetite Stimulation, Sensitive Stomach, Skin And Coat Health
Breed size
All
Performance notes
The casing-wrapped, semi-moist format with visible vegetable pieces is meant to look and feel more like a homemade meatloaf than a smooth pate, which some dogs find more appealing and others may be pickier about. Given the lower average rating here, it's worth reading recent reviews closely before committing to the larger 4 lb size.
What buyers say
With 227 reviews averaging 3.2 stars and no bought-last-month figure reported, this roll has one of the more mixed reception records in the category, suggesting inconsistent results across different dogs.
Why is the rating lower than other rolls in this category?
The 3.2 star average across 227 reviews is on the lower end for this category, so it's worth reading recent reviews to see whether reported issues match your dog's needs before buying the larger 4 lb size.
Is this roll wheat and corn free?
Yes, it's labeled corn-free and wheat-free, with carrot, kelp, spinach, and sweet potato as key ingredients alongside chicken.
Is this a good pick for a dog with a sensitive stomach?
Lucy Pet markets sensitive stomach support as one of its benefits, but given the mixed review history, it's worth introducing gradually and checking with your vet if your dog has ongoing digestive issues.
We use necessary cookies to keep the site working. With your permission, we also use functional, analytics, and marketing cookies. Read our Cookie Policy.
