Small Pet Select Premium Pine Pelleted Cat Litter, 100% All Natural Pellet Kitty Litter, Non Clumping Non Tracking Low Dust Litter Meant for Use with Sifting Litter Box, Made in USA, 25 lbs Review
By Marcus Bell · Dog nutrition editor · Published 2026-06-19 · Updated 2026-06-29
3.8(3,200)Amazon rating$28.99300+ bought last month
Our verdict
Small Pet Select's pine pelleted litter is a non clumping, all natural alternative built for sifting litter boxes, and its 3.8 star rating from 3,200 reviews suggests it works well for the right setup but isn't a universal fit.
Owners who already use, or are willing to switch to, a sifting litter box and want an all natural, non clumping pine pellet litter.
Skip if
You use a standard scoop litter box, since this pine pellet formula is designed around non clumping, sifting box use.
Form Pellet
Weight 25 Pounds
Priced 16% above the category median ($24.99 across 153 tracked models)
Our scorecard
3.8/5overall
Owner rating3.8/5
3.8 average across 3,200 owner ratings
Popularity3.1/5
3,200 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other dog and cat food, health, gear and grooming we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
["This litter is made from 100% pine pellets rather than clay or crystal, positioning it as an all natural option. It's non clumping and low dust, and Small Pet Select notes it's meant to be used with a sifting litter box, where pellets break down and sift through as they absorb moisture rather than forming clumps to scoop.", "It's manufactured in the USA and sold in a 25 pound bag, and the pet type is listed for cats as well as small animals, reflecting the brand's broader small pet product line.", 'The 3.8 star rating from 3,200 reviews is decent but noticeably lower than the clay based litters in this category, and at 300 units bought in the past month, demand is modest, which fits a more specialized non clumping format that not every household is set up to use.']
Pros
100% pine pellet formula for an all natural, non clumping option
Low dust design compared to typical clay litters
Made in the USA
Works across cats and other small animals per the listing
Cons
Requires a sifting litter box rather than a standard scoop box
Lower 3.8 star rating than most clay based litters in this category
Modest 300 units bought last month signals a smaller, niche audience
Specifications
Form
Pellet
Weight
25 Pounds
Performance notes
The pine pellet material is the defining feature, built as a non clumping alternative that relies on a sifting litter box to separate used pellets from fresh ones as moisture breaks them down, rather than forming solid clumps like clay litters. The low dust formulation is a plus for pouring and scooping, but the sifting box requirement is a real setup change for anyone coming from a standard clumping litter.
What buyers say
A 3.8 star average across 3,200 reviews is respectable but trails the clay based litters in this category, and the lower 300 units bought in the past month suggests this pine pellet format appeals to a smaller, more specific group of owners rather than the mass market.
The listing specifies this pine pellet litter is meant to be used with a sifting litter box, since it's non clumping and relies on sifting to separate used pellets rather than scooping clumps.
Can this litter be used for animals other than cats?
Yes, the listing lists the pet type as cat and small animal, reflecting Small Pet Select's broader small pet product range.
Why is the rating lower than other litters on this list?
At 3.8 stars from 3,200 reviews, it's a solid but more modest score, which likely reflects that non clumping pine pellet litter is a bigger adjustment for owners used to clay based clumping formulas.
We use necessary cookies to keep the site working. With your permission, we also use functional, analytics, and marketing cookies. Read our Cookie Policy.
