4.4(542)Amazon rating$146.99300+ bought last month
Our verdict
This Honest Kitchen Wholemade Fish formula is a limited ingredient, wild-caught fish dehydrated food aimed at dogs with sensitivities and allergies, and its 4.4 star average across 542 reviews reflects solid performance in a smaller, more specialized niche than the brand's whole grain lines.
Dogs with food sensitivities or allergies who do better on a limited ingredient, single protein fish diet.
Skip if
Your dog has a fish or seafood allergy, or you're looking for a lower cost option, since this 10 lb bag carries one of the higher price points in the dehydrated category.
Form Dry
Flavor Fish
Benefits Ideal For Dogs With Sensitivities And Allergies
Best for Allergy Relief
Breed size Medium
Weight 10 Pounds
Priced 213% above the category median ($46.95 across 29 tracked models)
Our scorecard
4.4/5overall
Owner rating4.4/5
4.4 average across 542 owner ratings
Popularity3.6/5
542 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other dog food and health supplements we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
['This 10 lb bag of The Honest Kitchen Wholemade Fish is a limited ingredient dehydrated food built around wild-caught fish, and like other Wholemade products it rehydrates into about 40 pounds of finished food. The limited ingredient approach is aimed squarely at dogs with sensitivities and allergies rather than being a general purpose formula.', "The Honest Kitchen markets this recipe as ideal for dogs with sensitivities and allergies, and it works as either a complete meal or a topper. It's positioned for young adult to adult dogs of medium breed size, using wild-caught fish as the single protein source to limit potential trigger ingredients.", 'At $146.99, this is one of the pricier options in the dehydrated dog food lineup, reflecting both the limited ingredient formulation and the larger 10 lb size. With 542 reviews at a 4.4 star average and about 300 purchases a month, it has a smaller but solid following, likely concentrated among owners specifically managing a sensitive or allergy-prone dog.']
Pros
Limited ingredient formula built around a single wild-caught fish protein
Marketed specifically for dogs with sensitivities and allergies
Rehydrates into about 40 pounds of finished food from a 10 lb bag
Works as a complete meal or a topper
Solid 4.4 star rating across 542 reviews
Cons
One of the higher price points in this category
Not the right choice for a dog with a fish or seafood allergy
Smaller review base than the brand's whole grain lines
Specifications
Form
Dry
Flavor
Fish
Benefits
Ideal For Dogs With Sensitivities And Allergies
Best for
Allergy Relief
Breed size
Medium
Weight
10 Pounds
Performance notes
The limited ingredient, single protein fish formulation is designed to reduce the number of potential allergens compared to multi-protein or whole grain recipes, which can make it easier to identify triggers if a dog is on an elimination diet, though this should be done under veterinary guidance.
What buyers say
A 4.4 star average across 542 reviews, with about 300 purchases a month, points to a smaller but dependable customer base, consistent with a specialized limited ingredient product rather than an everyday mainstream formula.
Why would I choose a limited ingredient formula over a standard one?
Limited ingredient formulas like this fish recipe are built with fewer components, which can help if your dog has a known or suspected food sensitivity, since there are fewer potential trigger ingredients in the bowl.
How much finished food does this 10 lb bag make?
The Honest Kitchen states this bag rehydrates into about 40 pounds of finished food, which helps offset the higher upfront price per bag.
Is this a complete meal or a topper?
It's labeled for both uses, so it can serve as your dog's full meal or be mixed into existing food as a topper, depending on your preference.
We use necessary cookies to keep the site working. With your permission, we also use functional, analytics, and marketing cookies. Read our Cookie Policy.
