Green Turks Ultrasonic Anti Barking Device Review Best Handheld Dog Bark Deterrent

Description

Testing the Handheld Ultrasonic Bark Deterrent: My Honest Experience

As someone who loves dogs but values a peaceful environment, I was curious to try out this ultrasonic dog bark deterrent. My Labrador, Luna, can get overly vocal when the doorbell rings or when the neighbors’ dog starts howling, and I needed something humane to curb her barking. This device promised a solution that was safe, portable, and effective. Here’s how it held up after weeks of testing in real-life situations.

Features and Functionality: A Deep Dive

The bark deterrent is a lightweight, handheld device that emits a high-frequency ultrasonic tone to interrupt barking. It’s marketed as an alternative to shock collars, which I’ve always been hesitant to use. The device is straightforward to operate: point it toward the barking dog and press the button. A visible LED indicator activates, followed by a beep and the ultrasonic tone.

What caught my eye was its range of up to 50 feet, which meant I could use it in various settings—indoors or outdoors. I tested it during walks, in my backyard, and even when Luna barked at the TV. While the tone is inaudible to humans, Luna definitely noticed it. Her ears perked up, and she stopped barking momentarily to figure out the source of the sound.

Another feature worth mentioning is its versatility. This isn’t just for your own dog; it works on other dogs too. My neighbor’s Chihuahua, who barks at anything that moves, seemed equally baffled by the noise.

Real-Life Use and Observations

Using this device consistently took some effort. It wasn’t a magic wand that stopped barking immediately. Luna needed repeated exposure to understand the pattern. Each time she barked, I activated the deterrent. Over time, she associated the beep and ultrasonic sound with her barking. After about a week, her barking significantly decreased, especially during predictable triggers like the mailman’s arrival.

However, I noticed some limitations. While Luna responded well, my friend’s stubborn German Shepherd wasn’t as impressed. He stopped for a moment but quickly resumed barking, almost ignoring the sound after a few uses. This device seems more effective for mild to moderate barkers rather than dogs with deeply ingrained habits.

Pros

• Humane and Safe: No shocks or pain involved, making it a guilt-free option for dog owners.
• Portable Design: The compact size fits easily in my pocket, making it convenient for walks or trips to the park.
• Versatile Usage: Works indoors and outdoors, plus it doesn’t require your dog to wear anything.
• Range of 50 Feet: Ideal for addressing barking even from a distance.
• Simple Operation: No complicated setup; just point, press, and it’s ready to go.

Cons

• Effectiveness Varies: Works better on some dogs than others, especially those who aren’t excessively stubborn.
• Training Required: Not an instant fix; consistent use is necessary for results.
• Limited Battery Life: Frequent use drains the battery, and replacement isn’t always convenient.
• Sensitivity of Range: Doesn’t always work at the advertised 50 feet if there are obstacles like walls or furniture.
• Noisy Environments: Less effective in areas with loud background noise.

Comparison to Competitors

Compared to bark collars, this device stands out for its humane approach. Unlike shock collars, which can scare or hurt dogs, the ultrasonic tone feels like a nudge rather than a punishment. However, collars like the BarxBuddy offer similar ultrasonic features with added vibration modes, which might be more effective for stubborn dogs.

Another competitor, the PetSafe Ultrasonic Bark Control, offers a tabletop version that covers larger areas but isn’t portable. For outdoor use or while walking, this handheld deterrent is far more convenient.

Where this product falters is in its consistency. Devices like the MODUS Ultrasonic Anti-Barking Device seem to have more reliable range and battery performance, though they come at a slightly higher price point.

Cost Analysis and Value for Money

Given its features, this bark deterrent sits at a reasonable price point compared to other solutions. It’s cheaper than most bark collars and doesn’t require additional purchases like straps, making it a budget-friendly choice. However, the cost-to-value ratio depends on your dog’s personality. If your dog is responsive to ultrasonic tones, this is a fantastic investment. On the other hand, for highly stubborn dogs, you might need to explore other options or combine this device with additional training methods.

Overall, while this bark deterrent isn’t perfect, it’s a solid option for dog owners seeking a humane, portable, and easy-to-use solution for mild to moderate barking issues.

Additional information